Comparing three poems (Project 3: Exercise 1)

Read the following extracts and decide how each poem contemplates the theme of ‘place’. Which one:

  • Speaks about place in relation to identity and exile?
  • Purely evokes a sense of place?
  • Makes a social comment about progress and place?

 

1.The Herefordshire Landscape by Elizabeth Barrett Browning

Hills, vales, woods, netted in a silver mist,

Farm, granges, doubled up among the hills,

And cattle grazing in the watered vales,

And cottage-chimneys smoking from the woods,

And cottage-gardens smelling everywhere,

Confused with smell of orchards.

 

My thoughts:

This poem speaks to me of place. Opening with geography and topography, she places farms, cattle and cottages in their place in this idyllic rural landscape. You can almost taste the mist and smell the apples and smoke!

 

2.Slough by John Betjeman

Come friendly bombs and fall on Slough!

It isn’t fit for humans now,

There isn’t grass to graze a cow.

Swarm over, Death!

Come, bombs and blow to smithereens

Those air-conditioned, bright canteens,

Tinned fruit, tinned meat, tinned milk, tinned beans,

Tinned minds, tinned breath.

 

My thoughts:

What a wonderful contrast! This is modern, urban living where there is nothing to sustain even a cow. Nothing relates to nature and the result is that people are imprisoned (“Tinned minds, tinned breath.”) Clearly this is social comment about urban life and supposed progress. 

3.The Lost Land by Eavan Boland

I can see the shore of Dublin Bay.

Its rocky sweep and its granite pier.

Is this, I say

how they must have seen it,

backing out on the mailboat at twilight,

shadows falling

on everything they had to leave?

And would love forever?

And then

I imagine myself

at the landward rail of that boat

searching for the last sight of a hand.

I see myself

on the underworld side of that water,

the darkness coming in fast, saying

all the names I know for a lost land:

Ireland. Absence. Daughter.

 

My thoughts:

Another wonderful contrast. This time we are not asked to look at a beautiful place or an ugly city. We are not being asked to consider its geography at all, rather we see Dublin Bay as it was seen by the members of the Irish diaspora. It is their home, their friends and their families that they are leaving. There is a real sense of melancholy in this poem as we realise The Bay is being seen for the last time. Hence the sense of exile.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s